Here’s a bold prediction: Andrew Benintendi’s approach at the plate is about to shift in a way that could redefine his role in the lineup—and it’s not just about hitting home runs anymore. But here’s where it gets controversial: Is prioritizing getting on base over power hitting the right move for a player who’s proven he can clear the fences? According to Mark Gonzales of the Chicago Sun-Times, Benintendi is gearing up to focus more on reaching base consistently in 2026, rather than chasing those long balls. This strategy might seem counterintuitive for someone who’s hit 20 home runs in back-to-back seasons, but there’s a method to his madness.
While Benintendi’s power numbers have been impressive, his on-base percentages of .289 and .307 over those same seasons tell a different story. He admits feeling the weight of expectations to deliver power, especially given the lack of pop in the lineup. And this is the part most people miss: With sluggers like Colson Montgomery and Munetaka Murakami set to join the everyday lineup in 2026, Benintendi sees an opportunity to shift his focus. By prioritizing getting on base, he can play to his strengths while letting the new power hitters do what they do best.
Off the field, Benintendi has been making adjustments too. After an Achilles injury sidelined him in July and lingered for the rest of the season, he shed weight this offseason to reduce strain on his body. This move isn’t just about recovery—it’s about sustainability and ensuring he can contribute consistently throughout the year.
Here’s the question that’ll spark debate: Is Benintendi’s new approach a smart adaptation to his team’s evolving lineup, or is he leaving valuable power potential on the table? Let’s be honest—in fantasy baseball, every decision matters. If you’re looking to dominate your league, understanding these strategic shifts is key. Speaking of which, if you’re serious about winning, consider unlocking RotoWire’s premium fantasy baseball tools. Sign up now and stay ahead of the game. (https://www.rotowire.com/subscribe/)
What do you think? Is Benintendi’s focus on getting on base a game-changer, or should he stick to what’s worked in the past? Drop your thoughts in the comments—let’s get the conversation started!
